Ontario wants to ban cottage country ‘floating homes’ made from shipping containers

Cottagers doubt proposed rule changes will have significant impact

A floating shipping container converted into a home sits on a lake.
A floating home made of two shipping containers is docked at a marina in Port Severn. The province is proposing to ban such floating accommodations from overnight stays on water over public land, which includes the beds of most lakes and rivers in Ontario. (Lotb.ca)

The Doug Ford government is aiming to slap restrictions on floating homes that are provoking controversy in Ontario’s cottage country.

The Ministry of Natural Resources and Forestry cites “an increase in the number and types of structures and things being used for overnight accommodation on Ontario’s lakes and rivers” as the reason behind proposed rule changes.

The changes would ban what the province describes as “float homes” and “barges with residential units” from overnight stays on water over public land, which includes the beds of most lakes and rivers in Ontario.

During consultations on the issue, the ministry received feedback that suggested the current rules for overnight accommodation on water are too permissive.

Graydon Smith, Ontario’s minister of natural resources, said in an interview that the intent of the proposal is to restrict large floating homes that are “outside the scope” of the boats typically seen on the province’s lakes and rivers.

“We want to get it right,” said Smith. “I do believe we’re on the right path.”

Photo of Graydon Smith in Queen's Park media studio
Graydon Smith, Ontario’s minister of natural resources and forestry, represents the cottage country riding of Parry Sound-Muskoka. (Evan Mitsui/CBC)

CBC News has previously reported on how cottagers and municipalities have raised concerns about shipping containers converted into floating accommodations on lakes in the Muskoka region.

Officials say the converted shipping containers are the chief target of the proposed regulation.

“The one thing we don’t want to be doing is ensnaring the traditional boating, cruising, sailing vessels that are a big part of Ontario and our tourism economy,” said Smith.

Transport Canada defines floating homes as vessels

What’s unclear is whether the proposed ban would succeed in restricting the floating shipping container homes.

That’s because Transport Canada has designated floating homes as vessels, which gives them the same rights as houseboats, motorboats or sailboats to anchor overnight in public navigable waters.

Transport Canada said in a statement that floating accommodations “are considered vessels — just like barges.”

The province’s proposed ban on floating accommodations defines them as “house-like structures incorporating a floatation system, intended for … residential or longer-term purposes and not primarily intended for, or usable in, navigation.”

Joe Nimens lives in cottage country year-round in a floating home constructed from a pair of 16-metre-long shipping containers, and is building six more for clients.

“Business is booming,” Nimens said in an interview from his floating home, docked at a marina in Port Severn, about 150 kilometres north of Toronto. “The one that we started first will be going in the water in the next few weeks.”

A photo of Joe Nimens sitting at a table inside his converted shipping container floating home, beside a window overlooking a lake.
Joe Nimens is pictured inside the floating home he built from two shipping containers. (CBC News)

Nimens says he suspects his floating homes are the province’s target.

“I believe that they’re trying to discourage us from doing what we’re doing, but I don’t see any way that the proposed regulation would affect us,” he said.

“Boats come in all kinds of sizes and shapes,” said Nimens. “I don’t have any idea what distinction [the province has] in mind between a floating accommodation and a vessel.”

Cottage owner calls move ‘a lot of hand-waving’

Nimens’ critics also doubt the province’s proposed ban on floating homes will shut him down.

“We really feel that these measures are meaningless,” said Cheryl Elliot-Fraser, president of the Gloucester Pool Cottagers’ Association, representing about 400 cottage owners on the large body of water that extends northeast from Port Severn.

A photo of Cheryl Elliot-Fraser outdoors with a lake in the background.
Cheryl Elliot-Fraser is president of the Gloucester Pool Cottagers’ Association. (Alexis Raymon/CBC News)

“We think (the Ministry of Natural Resources) is doing a lot of hand-waving,” said Claude Ricks, another member of the cottagers’ association. “They truly don’t understand the vessel designation trumps all.”

Township of Georgian Bay Mayor Peter Koetsier says he applauds the provincial government for doing what it can about the issue.

“I do appreciate the fact that they are recognizing that these floating accommodations, floating homes, whatever you like to call them, are not properly covered in the rules and regulations that currently exist,'” said Koetsier.

While Koetsier said the province’s proposed changes are part of the solution, he believes there will still be confusion over how they can operate unless Transport Canada changes its designation.

Photo of - February 27 Carling Budget Meeting

February 27 Carling Budget Meeting

Carling Council is in the process of finalizing the budget for 2024. There is a public meeting scheduled for February 27 at 9 a.m. The West Carling Association (WCA) strongly urges you to: Read the attached report (below). Attend the budget information session that is scheduled for February 27 - either virtually or in person. To gain access to the virtual meeting, please contact mtaylor@carling.ca Should you have any concerns regarding the budget, please feel free to express them during the meeting or in writing prior to the meeting. You may direct your written concerns to Mayor Murphy and our Councillors at: smurphy@carling.ca lcook@carling.ca adoubrough@carling.ca bkelly@carling.ca pwing@carling.ca The WCA has received an analysis of Carling's financial and operational data, which has been compared to the municipalities of Whitestone and McKellar. These two municipalities have similar populations and proportions of seasonal residents. The analysis was conducted by a member of the Pengally Bay Ratepayers Association, who has extensive financial management experience. The study has identified several areas of concern. Based on a data review conducted in 2017, it has been concluded that the residents of Carling are being overtaxed. The study reveals that we are paying 40 to 50 per cent (or more than $2.5 million) extra compared to the residents of Whitestone and McKellar for maintaining similar infrastructure and, in some cases, receiving fewer services. The following specific concerns were identified in the analysis: High staffing costs that continue to grow. Excessive reserves that continue to build up, resulting in interest payments on debt. The lack of involvement of Carling residents in decisions regarding the purpose and disposition of the reserves. Increasing taxes to build the reserves. Compared to Whitestone and McKellar, Carling is building higher reserves to fund the replacement of Township equipment and infrastructure ($3.8 million when only $168,000 is required by the Municipal Act). Building reserves for undefined purposes. Unexplained costs in the General Government Fund. The report concludes with several recommendations, including requesting that the Carling Council target tax reductions rather than continuing to increase our taxes. The WCA and the Pengally Bay Ratepayers Association have jointly drafted a letter expressing their concerns to the Carling Council. They have requested the council to take the following actions: Conduct a review of salaries and benefits in comparison to other jurisdictions. Conduct a full review of reserve funds in comparison to other jurisdictions. Form a financial subcommittee comprising one or more Carling residents with expertise in financial management (non-paid) to work with the council and staff. Additionally, they should assist in the budget analysis, monitor quarterly results and make recommendations to the council for remedial action if required. Adjust the 2024 budget to a zero per cent increase.   If you have any questions, please address them to info@westcarling.com   Carling 2024 Budget Analysis Final

Photo of - Response from Council on the Pool Project

Response from Council on the Pool Project

At the Carling Council budget meeting on February 9, Mayor Murphy noted that she had been reading notes that residents sent to her and the Councillors regarding the pool project and that she is concerned. She added that the Pool Board needs to keep Carling residents updated and that she would like to see a change. She requested that Councillors Kelly and Doubrough draw up a list of questions that Carling residents have asked to seek answers from the Pool Board, document them, and send them to all residents. She also suggested there needs to be an ongoing mechanism so residents can forward their questions to the Pool Board to get accurate, up-to-date information as the project progresses. It is very positive to hear our Mayor acknowledge concern about the lack of information being shared by the Pool Board. If you have specific questions for the Pool Board, please send them to Councillors Kelly and Doubrough and copy them to our mayor and Councillors Cook and Wing, as well as info@westcarling.ca. Their email addresses are below: smurphy@carling.ca lcook@carling.ca adoubrough@carling.ca bkelly@carling.ca pwing@carling.ca

Photo of - Agenda for the February 13 Council Meeting

Agenda for the February 13 Council Meeting

The agenda for the February 13th Council Meeting is now available. If you cannot attend in person and would like a meeting link, please email clerksoffice@carling.ca View the Council Meeting Agenda Here

Photo of - Update on Pool Project

Update on Pool Project

The West Carling Association (WCA) Board is deeply concerned about the pool project's financial sustainability, its potential impact on property taxes, the availability of funds for other crucial projects, and the overall cost/benefit ratio for Carling residents. The project's anticipated revenues from membership have been overestimated, its operating costs are underestimated, and fundraising challenges further suggest that more funding may be needed. Over the past few years, the WCA has sent several letters and emails to the Township of Carling expressing our concerns and requesting public consultation, but the Township has not acknowledged receipt or responded in a formal manner. The following letter was sent to Mayor Murphy and Carling Council, expressing our concerns about the pool project, asking questions, and requesting a public information session. Pool Report February 6 2024

Photo of - 2024 Winter Carnival

2024 Winter Carnival

The 2024 Carling Winter Carnival will take place at the Mike Konoval Community Hub (4 West Carling Bay Road) on Saturday, February 17, 2024. See the attached poster for details. View the 2024 Carling Winter Carnival Poster Here  

Photo of - Shawanaga First Nation/GBB Project Looks to Shed Light on Lake Sturgeon

Shawanaga First Nation/GBB Project Looks to Shed Light on Lake Sturgeon

Despite its cultural significance, little is known about the lake sturgeon of eastern Georgian Bay, but work between Shawanaga First Nation and Georgian Bay Mnidoo Gamii Biosphere (GBB) hopes to shed more light on the species at risk. With funding from the Aboriginal Fund for Species at Risk, Shawanaga took the lead on the four-year project that aims to fill some of the knowledge gaps left by the province’s Lake Sturgeon Recovery Strategy. Through fieldwork, interviews with community members and information gathering the project resulted in a lake sturgeon conservation plan for eastern Georgian Bay that can serve as a jumping-off point for future research. Read more here.

Photo of - Help Stop the Approval of the Pumped Storage Project at Meaford

Help Stop the Approval of the Pumped Storage Project at Meaford

https://georgianbay.ca/tc-energy/

Photo of - Waste Site Schedule

Waste Site Schedule

The waste site hours during the holidays are different than the regular hours. Please check the "Holiday Waste Site" schedule before heading out. Holiday Waste Site Schedule  

Photo of - Your Support is Needed to Stop the Meaford Pumped (Electricity) Storage Project

Your Support is Needed to Stop the Meaford Pumped (Electricity) Storage Project

TC Energy (TCE) proposes constructing a large pumped storage facility just north of Meaford on land owned by the Department of National Defence. The facility will occupy approximately 500 acres of land, including a man-made reservoir partially excavated into the escarpment, and extend 650 metres out into Georgian Bay. Over 6 billion gallons of water will be pumped approximately 150m up the escarpment through intake turbines to the reservoir/dam to be temporarily stored. It will then be released back into Georgian Bay to generate electricity, which will be transferred to the power grid near Barrie. This project will have Georgian Bay-wide impacts on water quality and biodiversity, and the pumped storage technology is outdated and only 72 per cent efficient. There is an opportunity this November to persuade the Ontario Ministry of Energy to drop its support for this project. Please consider sending an email through the GBA online portal to explain why this proposed project is a bad deal for Ontario and its taxpayers here.

View All News